The Legal Status of Following a Madhab 2017-11-23T17:16:14+05:00

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
الحمد للہ و کفی و سلام علی عبادہ الذین اصطفی‬‎


There is no dearth of books on the subject of taqIced and ijtihad and I had no idea that I would be writing anything on it. However, certain reasons compelled me to write down this treatise.
When, in 1963. the editor of Faran, Mahir ul-Qadri. suggested that I should contribute on article on taqleed. I was disinclined to engage in debate on the question, as, indeed, my respected father, Mawlana Mufti Muhammad Shafi, always kept himself away from it. However. I acceded to his request in the hope that I might explain the issue and invite the warring parties to think coolly and cease to argue.
Praise belongs to Allah. the article was well received when it was published in May 1963, in the Faran, and several other magazines of India and Pakistan and some Muslims of Junagadh reprinted it published it in the form of a booklet.
Nevertheless, though I had avoided a debate on the issue, the people, who disavow taqleed and reject that the imams of ijtihad should be followed responded with heavy criticism. Mawlana Muhammad Isma’il Salfi was one of them. His criticism was published in al-l’ism: in its thirteen issues and then annexed to his book Tahreek Azadi-e-Fikr aur Shah WaliuIIah ki Tajdeedi Masa’i.
Another response came from a man who accuses the imams of ijtihad as inventors of Shari’ah and their followers as infidels and polytheists and the Islamic fiqh as self-tailored. It was entitled al-Tahqeeq fi Jawab at-Taqleed.
A Third response was published in a monthly magazine of Hyderabad Daccon.
On my part. I retrained from engaging in the debate, as always had been mv wont. The articles had been read by many discerned people and had been published in India, so many friends desired that I should publish it in book form. Therefore, thirteen years later, I revised it in the light of the criticism and comments that had been made on it.
The original work has been enlarged and the criticism answered as part of text without referring to personalities as far as possible. Let me reiterate that this work is in no way an argument or debate. It is purely an academic approach aimed at explaining the stand of a vast majority of the ummah who follow the mujtahid imams. I have observed moderation and tried to give the view point of a large section of the ulama of ahl sunnat.
Therefore. I request my readers to follow the same scholarly path and avoid an argumentative approach. And, I hope I have been able to set at rest doubts and misgivings on the issue created by exaggerated propaganda by the careless.
May Allah accept my effort and make it beneficial for the Muslims.

وَمَا تَوْفِيقِي إِلَّا بِاللَّهِ عَلَيْهِ تَوَكَّلْتُ وَإِلَيْهِ أُنِيبُ

And only Allah has enabled me. In Him I place my trust and to Him is my return.

Muhammad Taqi Usmani
Friday night. Dar ul-Uloom
4th Jumadi uth Thani 1396. Karachi

Download PDF

Book Details